Evaluating the contribution of community informatics to rural development: the case of Malaysia's rural internet centres

PhD Thesis


Noor, Marhaini Mohd. 2012. Evaluating the contribution of community informatics to rural development: the case of Malaysia's rural internet centres. PhD Thesis Doctor of Philosophy. University of Southern Queensland.
Title

Evaluating the contribution of community informatics to rural development: the case of Malaysia's rural internet centres

TypePhD Thesis
Authors
AuthorNoor, Marhaini Mohd
SupervisorCockfield, Professor Geoff
Institution of OriginUniversity of Southern Queensland
Qualification NameDoctor of Philosophy
Number of Pages352
Year2012
Abstract

Telecentres in Malaysia were a policy response from the Malaysia government to address the digital divide between urban and rural communities. In the first instance, the main goal of the rural internet centres (RIC) program was to enhance rural access to information and communications technologies (ICTs) and to build human capital in ICT knowledge and skills in rural communities. The main goal of RIC program was extended over time and the RICs in each community were seen as a means for developing economic activity in rural communities through local entrepreneurship. The adoption of ICTs in rural regions may further enhance the effectiveness of RICs to the local communities. Social and economic benefits have been identified as important outcomes (perceived benefits). The objective of this study is to evaluate the perceived affects of RIC program on quality of rural life (QoRL).This study assesses the perceptions of stakeholders (RIC end-users and program managers) in regard to the impact of the RIC program on human capital of rural communities in Malaysia. The research questions were translated into three specific testable hypotheses. Despite that, the main research problem is, 'Can rural internet centres be an effective tool in bridging the digital divide for rural communities and improving rural quality of life?.' Thus this study is not evaluating if the divide is closing, however, it is evaluating if people perceived there is an improvement in their digital skills due to their use of RIC services.

This study is an evaluation of the RIC program in Malaysia, using a program logic framework to identify and evaluate inputs, outputs and outcomes of RIC program from multiple key stakeholder perspectives. Community informatics, end-user computing and social capital provided the theoretical lens for the program logic evaluation of the RIC program. An online survey of RIC users across 42 RICs was the main data collection method used to determine RIC users' perceptions and level of satisfaction with the services provided by RICs. And furthermore whether there is evidence of outcomes from the use of RIC services which could result in enhanced human capital. The main data collection phase was supplemented by a series of interviews with program managers and RIC managers from different regions and locations, some non-users and members of local RIC management committees. Finally some general observations about how RICs were operating were made during site visits to 11 RICs conduct interviews. The results of statistical analysis of the quantitative survey data and narratives determined from a content analysis of the interviews (qualitative) along with some RIC site observations (qualitative) are presented and discussed. The program logic framework of (1) inputs and outputs and (2) outcomes was used to guide these analyses in order to evaluate the RIC program. The quantitative and qualitative data collected for each stage of program logic framework were analysed, interpreted and triangulated in determining the key findings of this study.

There is generally strong support for the benefits of the RICs in building human capital, including improving job prospects and business opportunities for rural communities in Malaysia. The key findings also show that RICs are strongly associated with enhanced social capital although the causation effects may run both ways. The results are used to propose a model of the effects of community informatics, noting that many of the potential benefits may be intangible. Theoretically, this study has shown that the RIC improved the individual community QoRL with the use of ICT applications and services. Meanwhile, this thesis developed a comprehensive theoretical framework drawn from community informatics, end user computing and social capital theories to evaluate the RIC program. This is a new empirical contribution to the growing literature on the relationship between community informatics and social capital. The majority previous empirical studies on social capital have been conducted in sociology, whereas there is dearth of empirical studies which have evaluated the contribution of community informatics and social capital in telecentre programs; especially in developing countries such as Malaysia. Furthermore, there are few if any previous studies have evaluated an entire telecentre program such as the RIC program using program logic theory.

The research gap is whether the people perceive that there is an improvement in human and social capital as a result of the RICs. Thus these contribute to perceived effectiveness of the RIC program and improve in digital knowledge and skills in rural Malaysia. Hence, the contribution to practice is to build social capital policy while emphasise more on human capital approach in rural Malaysia. With the improvement on RIC program in Malaysia, i.e.; inputs, outputs and outcomes, this will leads to improvement on ICT for rural development. Therefore, this study makes a contribution primarily to the field of community informatics, drawing concepts from social capital, economic development, quality of rural life and rural development with reference to local rural communities in Malaysia.

Keywordsrural development; Malaysia; community informatics; internet centres; ICT; rural internet centres: RIC; rural communities; data collection
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020469999. Other information and computing sciences not elsewhere classified
460806. Human-computer interaction
400604. Network engineering
Byline AffiliationsFaculty of Business and Law
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q3158/evaluating-the-contribution-of-community-informatics-to-rural-development-the-case-of-malaysia-s-rural-internet-centres

Download files


Published Version
Noor__2012_whole.pdf
File access level: Anyone

  • 1764
    total views
  • 242
    total downloads
  • 3
    views this month
  • 2
    downloads this month

Export as