Educational malpractice: legal cases and educators' views

Article


Teh, Mui-Kim. 2008. "Educational malpractice: legal cases and educators' views." Education Journal. 36 (1-2), pp. 137-152.
Article Title

Educational malpractice: legal cases and educators' views

ERA Journal ID20044
Article CategoryArticle
Authors
AuthorTeh, Mui-Kim
Journal TitleEducation Journal
Journal Citation36 (1-2), pp. 137-152
Number of Pages16
Year2008
Place of PublicationShatin, Hong Kong
ISSN1364-4505
Abstract

The notion of being negligently and legally liable for poor teaching that results in the failure of students being able to achieve expected educational outcomes is an unimaginable prospect. However, there is an emerging trend of legal proceedings being brought against teachers, blaming them for low scores in literacy, numeracy or even the failure to pass an examination. The duty implied on educators to ensure the educational well-being of their students and the breach of such duty is what is commonly termed in the literature 'educational malpractice' or 'educational negligence'.
In this article, several cases relating to educational malpractice that took place in the U.S., the U.K., and Australia are reviewed, and the cases demonstrate that the courts are beginning to show a willingness to extend the tort of negligence to students' intellectual harm. The author then conducted a small-scale investigation to ascertain the views of school principals regarding this issue, with very interesting results.

Keywordsnegligence; administrator attitudes; court litigation; foreign countries; educational malpractice; principals; teacher competencies; teaching skills; educational quality; legal responsibility; low achievement; teacher responsibility
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020480506. Litigation, adjudication and dispute resolution
480499. Law in context not elsewhere classified
390402. Education assessment and evaluation
Public Notes

Chinese title : Jiaoyu Xuebao. Author Version not held.

Byline AffiliationsSchool of Law
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/9zvyx/educational-malpractice-legal-cases-and-educators-views

  • 2574
    total views
  • 11
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Principals and legal risk: complacency or concern?
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2009. "Principals and legal risk: complacency or concern?" ANZELA 2009: Education: A Risky Business? . Melbourne, Australia 30 Sep - 02 Oct 2009 Brisbane, Australia.
Singapore
Teh, Mui Kim and Stott, Kenneth. 2008. "Singapore." Russo, Charles J. and deGroof, Jan (ed.) The employment rights of teachers: exploring education law worldwide. Lanham, MD. Rowman & Littlefield Education. pp. 173-187
Children speaking up in Singapore: progress or peril
Teh, Mui Kim and Stott, Kenneth. 2005. "Children speaking up in Singapore: progress or peril." 14th Annual Conference of the Australia and New Zealand Education Law Association: Free Speech, Privacy & Property Rights in Education (ANZELA 2005). Freemantle, Western Australia 28 - 30 Sep 2005 Sydney, Australia.
Managing legal risk in schools: understanding diverse perspectives
Teh, Mui-Kim, Stott, Kenneth and Zuzarte, Dyan. 2004. "Managing legal risk in schools: understanding diverse perspectives." 13th Annual Conference of the Australia and New Zealand Education Law Association: Innovation & Internationalisation: Pushing the Boundaries of Education Law (ANZELA 2004). Wellington, New Zealand 22 - 24 Sep 2004 Brisbane, Australia.
Lessons in law
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2009. "Lessons in law." QCT Connection.
Spare the rod and spoil the child: should the abolition of corporal punishment be reversed?
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2010. "Spare the rod and spoil the child: should the abolition of corporal punishment be reversed?" ANZELA 2010: The Teaching Profession: Over Regulated?. Sydney, Australia 29 Sep - 01 Oct 2010 Sydney, Australia.
Keeping the lid on legal risk in schools: understanding different perspectives
Teh, Mui-Kim, Stott, Kenneth and Zuzarte, Dyan. 2004. "Keeping the lid on legal risk in schools: understanding different perspectives." Inaugural Academy of Principals APS Global Education Conference 2004. Singapore 06 - 09 Nov 2004 Singapore.
When is a reinstated pupil not reinstated?
Teh, Mui Kim and Stott, Kenneth. 2006. "When is a reinstated pupil not reinstated?" 15th Annual Conference of the Australia and New Zealand Education Law Association: Keeping People and Property Safe in an Education Environment (ANZELA 2006). Hobart, Tasmania 04 - 06 Oct 2006 Sydney, Australia.
Singapore school principals and the law: emerging trends from the international scene
Teh, Mui-Kim and Stott, Kenneth. 2003. "Singapore school principals and the law: emerging trends from the international scene." Educational Research Association of Singapore Conference 2003: Research In and On the Classroom. Singapore 19 - 21 Nov 2003 Singapore.
Four strategies to help keep you out of court
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2009. "Four strategies to help keep you out of court." School Business Affairs. 75 (9), pp. 9-12.
Student injuries and negligence: lessons from the international scene with implications for Singapore's educators
Teh, Kim. 2008. "Student injuries and negligence: lessons from the international scene with implications for Singapore's educators." International Journal of Educational Reform. 17 (4), pp. 341-354.
Globalisation, rights and issues in education law in Singapore
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2005. "Globalisation, rights and issues in education law in Singapore." International Journal for Education Law and Policy. 1 (1-2), pp. 119-131.
Schools and the law: emerging legal issues internationally with implications for school leaders in Singapore
Teh, Mui-Kim. 2008. Schools and the law: emerging legal issues internationally with implications for school leaders in Singapore. PhD Thesis Doctor of Philosophy. University of Southern Queensland.