Synthesis on the effectiveness of soil translocation for plant community restoration

Article


Gerrits, Gijs M., Waenink, Rik, Aradottir, Asa L., Buisson, Elise, Dutoit, Thierry, Ferreira, Maxmiller C., Fontaine, Joseph B., Jaunatre, Renaud, Kardol, Paul, Loeb, Roos, Ruiz, Sandra Magro, Maltz, Mia, Pärtel, Meelis, Peco, Begona, Piqueray, Julien, Pilon, Natashi A. L., Santa-Regina, Ignacio, Schmidt, Katharina T., Sengl, Philip, ..., Wubs, E. R. Jasper. 2023. "Synthesis on the effectiveness of soil translocation for plant community restoration." Journal of Applied Ecology. 60 (4), pp. 714-724. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.14364
Article Title

Synthesis on the effectiveness of soil translocation for plant community restoration

ERA Journal ID3267
Article CategoryArticle
AuthorsGerrits, Gijs M., Waenink, Rik, Aradottir, Asa L., Buisson, Elise, Dutoit, Thierry, Ferreira, Maxmiller C., Fontaine, Joseph B., Jaunatre, Renaud, Kardol, Paul, Loeb, Roos, Ruiz, Sandra Magro, Maltz, Mia, Pärtel, Meelis, Peco, Begona, Piqueray, Julien, Pilon, Natashi A. L., Santa-Regina, Ignacio, Schmidt, Katharina T., Sengl, Philip, van Diggelen, Rudy, Vieira, Daniel L. M., von Brackel, Wolfgang, Waryszak, Pawel, Wills, Tim J., Marrs, Rob H. and Wubs, E. R. Jasper
Journal TitleJournal of Applied Ecology
Journal Citation60 (4), pp. 714-724
Number of Pages11
Year2023
PublisherJohn Wiley & Sons
Place of PublicationUnited Kingdom
ISSN0021-8901
1365-2664
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2664.14364
Web Address (URL)https://besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1365-2664.14364
AbstractMany degraded ecosystems need active restoration to conserve biodiversity and re-establish ecosystem function, both highlighted targets of the UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration and the proposed EU Nature restoration law. Soil translocation, where both plant propagules and their associated soil biota are co-introduced, has increasingly been proposed as a powerful restoration technique for terrestrial ecosystems. However, a synthesis of the effectiveness of this method across ecosystems is lacking. To address how soil translocation affects restoration success, we performed a meta-analysis synthesizing data from 46 field experiments and their respective reference ecosystems in 17 countries across four continents. In each experiment, vegetation composition was recorded in response to soil translocation treatments and the resultant vegetational changes (diversity and composition) were quantified. We found that soil translocation leads to plant community development further away from the control and more towards the reference plant communities compared with treatments where only plant propagules were introduced. However, the variability of effect sizes among experiments was large, suggesting strong dependence of restoration success on restoration context. We found that restoration success was more likely on loamy soils and when translocation treatments were implemented over larger spatial areas (>180 m2). Furthermore, we found that restoration success either consistently increased or decreased over time depending on the experiment. Not only is this congruent with positive feedbacks between plant and soil communities driving plant community development, but it also suggests that the composition of the translocated plant and soil communities, and initial starting conditions, are critical for long-term restoration success. Synthesis and applications. Our analysis highlights soil translocation can be a successful restoration method across a broad range of ecosystems. However, its implementation needs to depend on a thorough evaluation of local conditions and the potential added value. Further refinement of soil translocation techniques is needed to increase success rates. © 2023 The Authors. Journal of Applied Ecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of British Ecological Society.

1. Many degraded ecosystems need active restoration to conserve biodiversity and re-establish ecosystem function, both highlighted targets of the UN Decade on Ecosystem Restoration and the proposed EU Nature restoration law. Soil translocation, where both plant propagules and their associated soil biota are co-introduced, has increasingly been proposed as a powerful restoration technique for terrestrial ecosystems. However, a synthesis of the effectiveness of this method across ecosystems is lacking.
2. To address how soil translocation affects restoration success, we performed a meta-analysis synthesizing data from 46 field experiments and their respective reference ecosystems in 17 countries across four continents. In each experiment, vegetation composition was recorded in response to soil translocation treatments and the resultant vegetational changes (diversity and composition) were quantified.
3. We found that soil translocation leads to plant community development further away from the control and more towards the reference plant communities compared with treatments where only plant propagules were introduced. However, the variability of effect sizes among experiments was large, suggesting strong dependence of restoration success on restoration context. We found that restoration success was more likely on loamy soils and when translocation treatments were implemented over larger spatial areas (>180 m2).
4. Furthermore, we found that restoration success either consistently increased or decreased over time depending on the experiment. Not only is this congruent with positive feedbacks between plant and soil communities driving plant community development, but it also suggests that the composition of the translocated plant and soil communities, and initial starting conditions, are critical for long-term restoration success.
5. Synthesis and applications. Our analysis highlights soil translocation can be a successful restoration method across a broad range of ecosystems. However, its implementation needs to depend on a thorough evaluation of local conditions and the potential added value. Further refinement of soil translocation techniques is needed to increase success rates.

Keywordsabove-ground–below-ground interactions; degraded soils, environmental filters; meta-analysis; restoration thresholds; soil inoculation; soil transfer
ANZSRC Field of Research 20204106. Soil sciences
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/z25w9/synthesis-on-the-effectiveness-of-soil-translocation-for-plant-community-restoration

  • 7
    total views
  • 3
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 1
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Direct and Indirect Effects of Climate Change in Coastal Wetlands: Will Climate Change Influence Wetlands by Affecting Plant Invasion?
Birnbaum, Christina, Waryszak, Pawel and Farrer, Emily C.. 2021. "Direct and Indirect Effects of Climate Change in Coastal Wetlands: Will Climate Change Influence Wetlands by Affecting Plant Invasion? " Wetlands: the journal of the Society of Wetland Scientists. 41 (5). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13157-021-01456-z
Plant and microbial impacts of an invasive species vary across an environmental gradient
Farrer, Emily C., Birnbaum, Christina, Waryszak, Pawel, Halbrook, Susannah R., Brady, Monica V., Bumby, Caitlin R., Candaele, Helena, Kulick, Nelle K., Lee, Sean F. H., Schroeder, Carolyn S., Smith, McKenzie K. H. and Wilber, William. 2021. "Plant and microbial impacts of an invasive species vary across an environmental gradient ." Journal of Ecology. 109 (5), pp. 2163-2176. https://doi.org/10.1111/1365-2745.13629
Best served deep: The seedbank from salvaged topsoil underscores the role of the dispersal filter in restoration practice
Waryszak, Pawel, Standish, Rachel J., Ladd, Philip G., Enright, Neal J., Brundrett, Mark and Fontaine, Joseph B.. 2021. "Best served deep: The seedbank from salvaged topsoil underscores the role of the dispersal filter in restoration practice." Applied Vegetation Science. 24 (1), p. e12539. https://doi.org/10.1111/avsc.12539
Planted mangroves cap toxic petroleum-contaminated sediments
Waryszak, Paweł, Palacios, Maria M., Carnell, Paul E., Yilmaz, I. Noyan and Macreadie, P.I.. 2021. "Planted mangroves cap toxic petroleum-contaminated sediments." Marine Pollution Bulletin. 171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2021.112746
Phragmites australis Associates with Belowground Fungal Communities Characterized by High Diversity and Pathogen Abundance
Schroeder, Carolyn S., Halbrook, Susannah, Birnbaum, Christina, Waryszak, Pawel, Wilber, William and Farrer, Emily C.. 2020. "Phragmites australis Associates with Belowground Fungal Communities Characterized by High Diversity and Pathogen Abundance ." Diversity. 12 (9). https://doi.org/10.3390/d12090363
Soil fungal responses to experimental warming and drying in a Mediterranean shrubland
Birnbaum, Christina, Hopkins, Anna J.M., Fontaine, Joseph B. and Enright, Enright. 2019. "Soil fungal responses to experimental warming and drying in a Mediterranean shrubland ." Science of the Total Environment. 683, pp. 524-536. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2019.05.222
Topsoil Stockpiling in Restoration: Impact of Storage Time on Plant Growth and Symbiotic Soil Biota
Birnbaum, Christina, Bradshaw, Laura Elizabeth, Ruthrof, Katinka Xoliswa and Fontaine, Joseph Benjamin. 2017. "Topsoil Stockpiling in Restoration: Impact of Storage Time on Plant Growth and Symbiotic Soil Biota ." Ecological Restoration. 35 (3), pp. 237-245. https://doi.org/10.3368/er.35.3.237
Sequential Disturbance Effects of Hailstorm and Fire on Vegetation in a Mediterranean-Type Ecosystem
Gower, K., Fontaine, J.B., Birnbaum, C. and Enright, N.J.. 2015. "Sequential Disturbance Effects of Hailstorm and Fire on Vegetation in a Mediterranean-Type Ecosystem ." Ecosystems. 18 (7), pp. 1121-1134. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10021-015-9886-5
Correlations between physical and chemical defences in plants: tradeoffs, syndromes, or just many different ways to skin a herbivorous cat?
Moles, Angela T., Peco, Begona, Wallis, Ian R., Foley, William J., Poore, Alistair G.B., Seabloom, Eric W., Vesk, Peter A., Bisigato, Alejandro J., Cella-Pizarro, Lucrecia, Clark, Connie J., Cohen, Philippe S., Cornwell, William K., Edwards, Will, Ejrnaes, Rasmus, Gonzales-Ojeda, Therany, Graae, Bente J., Hay, Gregory, Lumbwe, Fainess C., Magana-Rodriguez, Benjamın, ..., Hui, Francis K. C.. 2013. "Correlations between physical and chemical defences in plants: tradeoffs, syndromes, or just many different ways to skin a herbivorous cat?" New Phytologist. 198 (1), pp. 252-263. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.12116