Experiencing new public management: employee reaction to flexible work practices and performance management

Paper


Rose, Dennis M. and Waterhouse, Jennifer M.. 2004. "Experiencing new public management: employee reaction to flexible work practices and performance management." 2004 Industrial Relations in European Conference (IREC). Utrecht, Netherlands 26 - 28 Aug 2004
Paper/Presentation Title

Experiencing new public management: employee reaction to flexible work practices and performance management

Presentation TypePaper
AuthorsRose, Dennis M. (Author) and Waterhouse, Jennifer M. (Author)
Journal or Proceedings Title2004 Industrial Relations in European Conference (IREC)
Number of Pages19
Year2004
Conference/Event2004 Industrial Relations in European Conference (IREC)
Event Details
2004 Industrial Relations in European Conference (IREC)
Event Date
26 to end of 28 Aug 2004
Event Location
Utrecht, Netherlands
Abstract

Performance measurement in the public sector has been problematic compared to the private sector. This is due to the absence of a readily identifiable and measurable single goal. Notwithstanding, better performance and the measurement of it significantly underpins the ‘New Public Management’ (NPM) philosophy, which has been widely adopted in various forms throughout much of the English-speaking western world. NPM, although amorphous and variously defined, represents broadly a descriptive approach to the adoption of private sector management, reporting and accounting methods in the public sector. The 1980s saw the beginnings of purposeful change in realigning the public sector with NPM philosophies. Hood's (1991) identification of the manifestations of NPM, the 'steering not rowing' metaphor from Osborne and Gaebler’s (1992) Reinventing Government, and support for NPM through the Thatcher administration and in the Clinton election campaign, gave form to theory, and provided a catch-all for innovation and change more generally occurring (Dunleavy and Hood, 1994; Denhardt and Denhardt, 2000).

The themes of NPM became firmly established within the Australian public sector through the National Competition Policy (Hilmer, 1993). This policy was agreed to by all state governments in Australia stipulating that 'all business should be subject to the market unless it constitutes core operations; micro-economic reform; a push for efficiency and effectiveness in the provision of services; and efforts to provide greater choice and more holistic services for clients' (in Chalmers and Davis, 2001: 80). The public sector in Australia therefore adopted various NPM practices including the implementation of hands-on professional management, explicit standards and measures of performance and a stress on private sector styles of management practice (Hood, 1991).

Contemporaneous to the implementation of most aspects of NPM in Australia, the industrial relations system was subjected to increasing decentralisation. A system of enterprise level bargaining largely replaced a central system of national and state awards. The objectives of the new industrial relations system were to address productivity improvements at workplace level. In 1994 the enterprise bargaining framework was implemented in the public sector to provide the institutional means to organise workplace arrangements in which pay rises were linked to increased efficiency and productivity. This provided the impetus and the environment necessary for the implementation of performance measurement, performance management and more flexible work arrangements.

This paper considers the impact of the implementation of performance management and flexible work practices on quality of work and staff morale within a large public sector agency in the state of Queensland. A review of the public sector and industrial relations environment in Australia is conducted that demonstrates how the institutional arrangements were conducive to the implementation of NPM philosophies. A case study is then presented wherein a survey of innovative HRM practices implementation was administered to a sample of approximately 170 work groups in the participating agency. This was followed three months later by a climate survey of all staff (n=4,300). Detailed analysis using structural equation modelling showed that flexible work practices were particularly important to job satisfaction, quality of work life and stress; incentive practices were positively related to morale; and work design practices were not uniquely related to the outcome variables selected. Concurrently, qualitative data was gathered through a series of interviews and focus groups and analysed in regard to staff's perceptions and experiences of flexible work practices and performance management.

Keywordsperformance management; public sector; flexible work; industrial relations
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020350504. Industrial and employee relations
520104. Industrial and organisational psychology (incl. human factors)
Public Notes

This is the Accepted Version of the paper. Formal proceedings were not published.

Byline AffiliationsQueensland University of Technology
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/9zw61/experiencing-new-public-management-employee-reaction-to-flexible-work-practices-and-performance-management

Download files


Accepted Version
Rose_Waterhouse_IREC_2004_AV.pdf
File access level: Anyone

  • 2495
    total views
  • 912
    total downloads
  • 2
    views this month
  • 13
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

The potential influence of prior work experience on unfair dismissal arbitration decisions related to employee misconduct: an exploratory study of decision styles
Southey, Kim, Lynch, Bernadette, Rose, Dennis and Hafeez-Baig, Abdul. 2023. "The potential influence of prior work experience on unfair dismissal arbitration decisions related to employee misconduct: an exploratory study of decision styles ." Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources. 61 (3), pp. 582-612. https://doi.org/10.1111/1744-7941.12366
Leadership and individual cognitive differences in followers: lessons from a consideration of distributed leadership
Rose, Dennis Michael and Gordon, Raymond. 2011. "Leadership and individual cognitive differences in followers: lessons from a consideration of distributed leadership." 25th Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management Conference (ANZAM 2011). Wellington, New Zealand 07 - 09 Dec 2011 Brisbane, Australia.
The BGR contingency model for leading change
Brown, Derek R., Gordon, Raymond and Rose, Dennis Michael. 2012. "The BGR contingency model for leading change." International Journal of Learning and Change. 6 (1/2 ), pp. 66-78. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJLC.2012.045857
Sustainable education in the western corridor: the research roadmap ahead
Rose, Denis, Ally, Mustafa, Cassidy, Frances, Gardiner, Michael and Hume, Margee. 2011. "Sustainable education in the western corridor: the research roadmap ahead." Building Business Communities: Justice, Performance and Change Creating a Sustainable Scholarly Community Colloquia (2011). Brisbane, Australia 09 Nov 2011 Toowoomba, Australia.
Retention of engineering and technical professionals in a state public transport organisation
Rose, Dennis M. and Gordon, Raymond. 2007. "Retention of engineering and technical professionals in a state public transport organisation." Chapman, Ross (ed.) 21st Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management Conference (ANZAM 2007). Sydney, Australia 04 - 07 Dec 2007 Melbourne, Australia.
Testing planning organising, leading and controlling (POLC): an empirical examination of the functions of management through a pilot study developing the 'POLC-BMS'
Gordon, Raymond, Rose, Dennis M. and Bushel, H.. 2009. "Testing planning organising, leading and controlling (POLC): an empirical examination of the functions of management through a pilot study developing the 'POLC-BMS'." Beaumont, Nicholas (ed.) 23rd Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management Conference (ANZAM 2009). Melbourne, Australia 01 - 04 Dec 2009 Melbourne, Australia.
The importance of individual mental models for strategic thinking in organisations
Malan, Renee, Erwee, Ronel and Rose, Dennis M.. 2009. "The importance of individual mental models for strategic thinking in organisations." Beaumont, Nicholas (ed.) 23rd Australian and New Zealand Academy of Management Conference (ANZAM 2009). Melbourne, Australia 01 - 04 Dec 2009 Melbourne, Australia.
Retention practices for engineering and technical professionals in an Australian public agency
Rose, Dennis Michael and Gordon, Ray. 2010. "Retention practices for engineering and technical professionals in an Australian public agency." Australian Journal of Public Administration. 69 (3), pp. 314-325. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-8500.2010.00693.x
Graduate employment preferences: implications for 'New Public Management' agencies.
Rose, Dennis M. and Waterhouse, Jennifer M.. 2005. "Graduate employment preferences: implications for 'New Public Management' agencies. " 9th International Research Symposium on Public Management (IRSPM IX). Milan, Italy 06 - 08 Apr 2005
Pathway to responsible leadership
Rose, Dennis, Gordon, Ray and Hattingh, Waldo. 2010. "Pathway to responsible leadership." 1st International Conference in Responsible Leadership: The Next Generation Responsible Leaders. Pretoria, South Africa 18 - 20 May 2010 Pretoria, South Africa.