Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?
Article
Close, Eliana, Young, Simon, Cockburn, Tina, Willmott, Lindy and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?" University of New South Wales Law Journal. 44 (1), pp. 9-59. https://doi.org/10.53637/FSJG1698
| Article Title | Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia? |
|---|---|
| ERA Journal ID | 33965 |
| Article Category | Article |
| Authors | Close, Eliana (Author), Young, Simon (Author), Cockburn, Tina (Author), Willmott, Lindy (Author) and White, Ben P. (Author) |
| Journal Title | University of New South Wales Law Journal |
| Journal Citation | 44 (1), pp. 9-59 |
| Number of Pages | 51 |
| Year | 2021 |
| Publisher | University of New South Wales |
| Place of Publication | Australia |
| ISSN | 0313-0096 |
| 1447-7297 | |
| Digital Object Identifier (DOI) | https://doi.org/10.53637/FSJG1698 |
| Web Address (URL) | https://www.unswlawjournal.unsw.edu.au/article/legal-challenges-to-icu-triage-decisions-in-the-covid-19-pandemic-how-effectively-does-the-law-regulate-bedside-rationing-decisions-in-australia/ |
| Abstract | The COVID-19 pandemic has raised the difficult question of how to ration scarce intensive care resources when a health system is overwhelmed. Despite substantial ethical scholarship addressing these rationing decisions, little is known about the legal position in Australia. This article considers various legal challenges in response to a clinical scenario denying intensive care admission and a ventilator to a critically ill patient with COVID-19. The article considers key challenges in negligence, criminal law, administrative law, human rights law, and under the parens patriae jurisdiction and guardianship legislation, and how they would apply to this scenario. The article concludes that while there are many obstacles to a successful legal challenge, the law can provide important scrutiny and guidance in the design of decision-making processes and triage policies. To adequately protect individual interests, the article supports calls in the ethical literature to make these policies transparent for public scrutiny. |
| Keywords | COVID-19; policy; triage; risk; rationing; resources; challenges |
| Contains Sensitive Content | Does not contain sensitive content |
| ANZSRC Field of Research 2020 | 420306. Health care administration |
| 480605. Tort law | |
| 480701. Administrative law | |
| Public Notes | Files associated with this item cannot be displayed due to copyright restrictions. |
| Byline Affiliations | Queensland University of Technology |
| School of Law and Justice | |
| Institution of Origin | University of Southern Queensland |
Permalink -
https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q6w10/legal-challenges-to-icu-triage-decisions-in-the-covid-19-pandemic-how-effectively-does-the-law-regulate-bedside-rationing-decisions-in-australia
69
total views4
total downloads1
views this month0
downloads this month
Export as
Related outputs
Indigenous Rights in Freshwater: Mapping the Contested Space in Australia, New Zealand and Canada
Young, Simon, Down, Sarah and Mascher, Sharon. 2023. "Indigenous Rights in Freshwater: Mapping the Contested Space in Australia, New Zealand and Canada." Environmental and Planning Law Journal. 39 (3), pp. 276-301.Community Knowledge of Law on End-of-life Decision-making: An Australian Telephone Survey
Tilse, Cheryle, Wilson, Jill, White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Lawson, Deborah, Dunn, Jeffrey, Aitken, Joanne F., Pearce, Angela and Ferguson, Michele. 2019. "Community Knowledge of Law on End-of-life Decision-making: An Australian Telephone Survey." Journal of Law and Medicine. 27 (2), pp. 399-414.Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018
Osborne, Sonya R., Cockburn, Tina and Davis, Juliet. 2021. "Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018." Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 14, pp. 2397-2413. https://doi.org/10.2147/JMDH.S316166The Blue Sky Effect: a repatriation of judicial review or a search for flexibility?
Young, Simon. 2020. "The Blue Sky Effect: a repatriation of judicial review or a search for flexibility?" Australian Journal of Administrative Law. 27 (3), pp. 165-179.Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018
Osborne, Sonya, Cockburn, Tina and Davis, Juliet. 2022. "Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018." Journal of Perioperative Nursing. 35 (2), pp. e-49-e-65. https://doi.org/10.26550/2209-1092.1202Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians
Close, Eliana, Willmott, Lindy, Cockburn, Tina, Young, Simon, Cairns, Will and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians." Medical Journal of Australia. 215 (2), pp. 71-74.e1. https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.51079