Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?

Article

Close, Eliana, Young, Simon, Cockburn, Tina, Willmott, Lindy and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?" University of New South Wales Law Journal. 44 (1), pp. 9-59. https://doi.org/10.53637/FSJG1698
Article Title

Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?

ERA Journal ID33965
Article CategoryArticle
AuthorsClose, Eliana (Author), Young, Simon (Author), Cockburn, Tina (Author), Willmott, Lindy (Author) and White, Ben P. (Author)
Journal TitleUniversity of New South Wales Law Journal
Journal Citation44 (1), pp. 9-59
Number of Pages51
Year2021
PublisherUniversity of New South Wales
Place of PublicationAustralia
ISSN0313-0096
1447-7297
Digital Object Identifier (DOI)https://doi.org/10.53637/FSJG1698
Web Address (URL)https://www.unswlawjournal.unsw.edu.au/article/legal-challenges-to-icu-triage-decisions-in-the-covid-19-pandemic-how-effectively-does-the-law-regulate-bedside-rationing-decisions-in-australia/
Abstract

The COVID-19 pandemic has raised the difficult question of how to ration scarce intensive care resources when a health system is overwhelmed. Despite substantial ethical scholarship addressing these rationing decisions, little is known about the legal position in Australia. This article considers various legal challenges in response to a clinical scenario denying intensive care admission and a ventilator to a critically ill patient with COVID-19. The article considers key challenges in negligence, criminal law, administrative law, human rights law, and under the parens patriae jurisdiction and guardianship legislation, and how they would apply to this scenario. The article concludes that while there are many obstacles to a successful legal challenge, the law can provide important scrutiny and guidance in the design of decision-making processes and triage policies. To adequately protect individual interests, the article supports calls in the ethical literature to make these policies transparent for public scrutiny.

KeywordsCOVID-19; policy; triage; risk; rationing; resources; challenges
Contains Sensitive ContentDoes not contain sensitive content
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020420306. Health care administration
480605. Tort law
480701. Administrative law
Public Notes

Files associated with this item cannot be displayed due to copyright restrictions.

Byline AffiliationsQueensland University of Technology
School of Law and Justice
Institution of OriginUniversity of Southern Queensland
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q6w10/legal-challenges-to-icu-triage-decisions-in-the-covid-19-pandemic-how-effectively-does-the-law-regulate-bedside-rationing-decisions-in-australia

Log in to edit
  • 106
    total views
  • 4
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

'Who Built This Fence?': Regenerating Faculty Landscapes for Lasting Education Reform
Young, Simon and Smith, Kirstie. 2025. "'Who Built This Fence?': Regenerating Faculty Landscapes for Lasting Education Reform." Watson, Nicole and Douglas, Heather (ed.) Legal Education through an Indigenous Lens: Decolonising the Law School. United States. Routledge. pp. 71-86
Integrating Sustainable Development Goals in the Law Curriculum: Legal Education for "People, Planet and Prosperity"
Karim, Md Saiful, Deane, Felicity, Arif, Abdullah Al, Garwood-Gowers, Andrew, Humphries, Fran, Uddin, Md Mahatab, Akhtar-Khavari, Afshin, Maguire, Rowena, Lewis, Bridget, Cradduck, Lucy, Robb, Lachlan, Cockburn, Tina, Purser, Kelly, Boyle, Sam, Matthew, Anne, Wang, Brydon and Deagon, Alex. 2024. "Integrating Sustainable Development Goals in the Law Curriculum: Legal Education for "People, Planet and Prosperity"." Belmont Law Review. 12 (1), pp. 196-231.
Seven Structural Changes to help bring Indigenous Perspectives into Curricula
Smith, Kirstie and Young, Simon. 2024. "Seven Structural Changes to help bring Indigenous Perspectives into Curricula." Times Higher Education (THE).
Swanbank Power Station (former) CMP: A preliminary Conservation Management Plan prepared for CleanCo Queensland Ltd for the Swanbank Clean Energy Hub
Hill, Susan, Pocock, Celmara, Batorowicz, Beata, Gharineiat, Zahra and Young, Simon. 2024. Swanbank Power Station (former) CMP: A preliminary Conservation Management Plan prepared for CleanCo Queensland Ltd for the Swanbank Clean Energy Hub. Australia. University of Southern Queensland. https://doi.org/10.26192/z8819
'For Our Elders': An Australian First Nations Elders of Ipswich Project
Davidson-Fewquandie, Carla Carla, Collins, Rachael, Best, Odette, Young, Simon, Smith, Kirstie, Castro, Jason and Batorowicz, Beata. 2024. 'For Our Elders': An Australian First Nations Elders of Ipswich Project. Ipswich, Australia 02 - 09 Jul 2023
Indigenous Rights in Freshwater: Mapping the Contested Space in Australia, New Zealand and Canada
Young, Simon, Down, Sarah and Mascher, Sharon. 2023. "Indigenous Rights in Freshwater: Mapping the Contested Space in Australia, New Zealand and Canada." Environmental and Planning Law Journal. 39 (3), pp. 276-301.
Community Knowledge of Law on End-of-life Decision-making: An Australian Telephone Survey
Tilse, Cheryle, Wilson, Jill, White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Lawson, Deborah, Dunn, Jeffrey, Aitken, Joanne F., Pearce, Angela and Ferguson, Michele. 2019. "Community Knowledge of Law on End-of-life Decision-making: An Australian Telephone Survey." Journal of Law and Medicine. 27 (2), pp. 399-414.
Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018
Osborne, Sonya R., Cockburn, Tina and Davis, Juliet. 2021. "Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018." Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare. 14, pp. 2397-2413. https://doi.org/10.2147/JMDH.S316166
The Blue Sky Effect: a repatriation of judicial review or a search for flexibility?
Young, Simon. 2020. "The Blue Sky Effect: a repatriation of judicial review or a search for flexibility?" Australian Journal of Administrative Law. 27 (3), pp. 165-179.
Commentary: members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422
Young, Simon. 2021. "Commentary: members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422." Watson, Nicole and Douglas, Heather (ed.) Indigenous Legal Judgments: Bringing Indigenous Voices into Judicial Decision Making. United Kingdom. Routledge. pp. 92-111
Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018
Osborne, Sonya, Cockburn, Tina and Davis, Juliet. 2022. "Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018." Journal of Perioperative Nursing. 35 (2), pp. e-49-e-65. https://doi.org/10.26550/2209-1092.1202
Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians
Close, Eliana, Willmott, Lindy, Cockburn, Tina, Young, Simon, Cairns, Will and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians." Medical Journal of Australia. 215 (2), pp. 71-74.e1. https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.51079
If COVID hospitalisations increase, it’s still not clear how patients will be prioritised for ICU beds
Close, Eliana, White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Young, Simon, Cockburn, Tina and Cairns, Will. 2021. "If COVID hospitalisations increase, it’s still not clear how patients will be prioritised for ICU beds." The Conversation.
The 'Blue Sky effect': a repatriation of judicial review grounds or a search for flexibility?
Young, Simon. 2020. "The 'Blue Sky effect': a repatriation of judicial review grounds or a search for flexibility?" AIAL Forum. 2020 (98), pp. 54-69.
Constitutional promises of Indigenous recognition: Canada, Vanuatu and the challenges of pluralism
Corrin, Jennifer and Young, Simon. 2019. "Constitutional promises of Indigenous recognition: Canada, Vanuatu and the challenges of pluralism." Common Law World Review. 48 (4), pp. 233-265. https://doi.org/10.1177/1473779519891623
Retained Surgical Items: Lessons from Australian Case Law of Items Unintentionally Left Behind in Patients after Surgery
Cockburn, Tina, Davis, Juliet and Osborne, Sonya. 2019. "Retained Surgical Items: Lessons from Australian Case Law of Items Unintentionally Left Behind in Patients after Surgery." Journal of Law and Medicine. 26 (4), pp. 841-848.
The increments of justice: exploring the outer reach of Akiba's edge towards native title 'ownership'
Young, Simon. 2019. "The increments of justice: exploring the outer reach of Akiba's edge towards native title 'ownership'." University of New South Wales Law Journal. 42 (3), pp. 825-868. https://doi.org/10.53637/PZOJ4201
'The difficulties of communication encountered by Indigenous peoples’: moving beyond Indigenous deficit in the model admission rules for legal practitioners
Burns, Marcelle, Young, Simon and Nielsen, Jennifer. 2018. "'The difficulties of communication encountered by Indigenous peoples’: moving beyond Indigenous deficit in the model admission rules for legal practitioners." Legal Education Review. 28 (2), pp. 1-27.
The evolution of bias: spectrums, species and the weary lay observer
Young, Simon. 2017. "The evolution of bias: spectrums, species and the weary lay observer." Melbourne University Law Review. 41 (2), pp. 928-956.
Community knowledge of law at the end of life: Availability and accessibility of web-based resources
White, Ben, Willmott, Lindy, Tilse, Cheryl, Wilson, Jill, Lawson, Deborah, Pearce, Angela, Dunn Jeffrey, Aitken, Joanne F., Feeney, Rachel and Jowett, Stephanie. 2018. "Community knowledge of law at the end of life: Availability and accessibility of web-based resources." Australian Health Review. 42 (3), pp. 266-271. https://doi.org/10.1071/AH16234
From the bike to the bus: the Noongar Native Title settlement
Young, Simon. 2013. "From the bike to the bus: the Noongar Native Title settlement." Native Title Newsletter.
The troubled sequel: Canadian aboriginal title revisited in the BC Court of Appeal
Young, Simon. 2012. "The troubled sequel: Canadian aboriginal title revisited in the BC Court of Appeal." Australian Property Law Bulletin. 26 (10), pp. 147-150.
Rights-based 'recognition': the Canadian experience
Mascher, Sharon and Young, Simon. 2016. "Rights-based 'recognition': the Canadian experience." Young, Simon, Nielsen, Jennifer and Patrick, Jeremy (ed.) Constitutional recognition of first peoples in Australia - theories and comparative perspectives. Leichhardt, NSW, Australia. Federation Press. pp. 176-205
Synergy or skirmish? The collaboration of law and anthropology
Young, Simon. 2016. "Synergy or skirmish? The collaboration of law and anthropology." Bright, Susan and Blandy, Sarah (ed.) Researching property law. London, United Kingdom. Palgrave Macmillan. pp. 145-163
A climate for change? The 2009 Native Title report
Young, Simon. 2010. "A climate for change? The 2009 Native Title report." Indigenous Law Bulletin. 7 (18), pp. 20-24.
Privative clauses: politics, legality and the constitutional dimension
Young, Simon. 2014. "Privative clauses: politics, legality and the constitutional dimension." Groves, Matthew (ed.) Modern administrative law in Australia: concepts and context. Port Melbourne. Cambridge University Press. pp. 276-297
Law and anthropology: the unhappy marriage?
Young, Simon. 2014. "Law and anthropology: the unhappy marriage?" Property Law Review. 2014 (3), pp. 236-246.
The trouble with tradition: native title and cultural change
Young, Simon. 2008. The trouble with tradition: native title and cultural change. Sydney, Australia. Federation Press.
Administrative law in Australia
Lane, W. B. and Young, Simon. 2007. Administrative law in Australia. Sydney, Australia. Lawbook Co..
Cultural timelessness and colonial tethers: Australian native title in historical and comparative perspective
Young, Simon. 2008. "Cultural timelessness and colonial tethers: Australian native title in historical and comparative perspective." Australian Indigenous Law Review. 12, pp. 60-68.
Law and custom - 'Tradition': the assembly of a legal microscope [submitted to Australian Law Reform Commission]
Young, Simon. 2009. Law and custom - 'Tradition': the assembly of a legal microscope [submitted to Australian Law Reform Commission]. Unpublished.
Native title in Canada and Australia post Tsilhqot'in: shared thinking or ships in the night?
Young, Simon. 2009. "Native title in Canada and Australia post Tsilhqot'in: shared thinking or ships in the night?" Land, Rights, Laws: Issues of Native Title. 4 (2), pp. 1-16.
Probing the frontiers of administrative law
Johnston, Peter, Young, Simon, Hooker, Richard and Pontre, Tom. 2011. "Probing the frontiers of administrative law." ALIAL Forum. 67, pp. 1-34.
An elegant convergence? The constitutional entrenchment of 'jurisdictional error' review in Australia
Young, Simon and Murray, Sarah. 2011. "An elegant convergence? The constitutional entrenchment of 'jurisdictional error' review in Australia." Oxford University Commonwealth Law Journal. 11 (2), pp. 117-142.
Tides of history and jurisprudential gulfs: Native title proof and the Noongar Western Australia claim
Young, Simon. 2010. "Tides of history and jurisprudential gulfs: Native title proof and the Noongar Western Australia claim." Indigenous Law Journal. 8 (1), pp. 95-120.
One step forward and one step back: the Noongar South-West Native Title Claim
Young, Simon. 2008. "One step forward and one step back: the Noongar South-West Native Title Claim." Australian Property Law Bulletin. 23 (2), pp. 14-17.