Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018
Article
Article Title | Exploring Risk, Antecedents and Human Costs of Living with a Retained Surgical Item: A Narrative Synthesis of Australian Case Law 1981–2018 |
---|---|
ERA Journal ID | 123846 |
Article Category | Article |
Authors | Osborne, Sonya R. (Author), Cockburn, Tina (Author) and Davis, Juliet (Author) |
Journal Title | Journal of Multidisciplinary Healthcare |
Journal Citation | 14, pp. 2397-2413 |
Number of Pages | 17 |
Year | 2021 |
Place of Publication | United Kingdom |
ISSN | 1178-2390 |
Digital Object Identifier (DOI) | https://doi.org/10.2147/JMDH.S316166 |
Web Address (URL) | https://www.dovepress.com/exploring-risk-antecedents-and-human-costs-of-living-with-a-retained-s-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-JMDH |
Abstract | Objective(s): This study aimed to critically examine the circumstances contributing to, and the human costs arising from, the retention of surgical items through the lens of Australian case law. Design, Setting and Participants: We reviewed Australian cases from 1981 to 2018 to establish a pattern of antecedents and identify long-term patient impacts (human costs) of retained surgical items. We used a modified four-step process to conduct a systematic review of legal doctrine, combined with a narrative synthesis approach to bring the information together for understanding. We searched LexisNexis, AustLII, Coroner Court websites, Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency Tribunal Decisions and Panel Hearings, Civil and Administrative Tribunal summaries, and other online sources for publicly available civil cases, medical disciplinary cases, coronial cases, and criminal cases across all Australian jurisdictions. Results: Ten cases met the inclusion criteria, including one coronial case, three civil appeal cases, and six civil first instance cases. Time from item retention to discovery ranged from 12 days to 20 years, with surgical sponges the most frequently retained item. Five case reports indicated possible deviations from standard protocols regarding counting procedures and record-keeping. In the four cases that reported on count status, the count was deemed correct at the end of surgery. Case reports also showed the human costs of retained surgical items, that is, the long-term impacts on patients associated with a retained surgical item. In eight of the nine civil cases, ongoing pain was the most frequently reported physical symptom; in three cases, patients suffered psychosocial symptoms requiring treatment. Conclusion: While there was little uniformity in the items retained or how items came to be retained, we identified significant time delays between item retention and item discovery, coupled with long-lasting physical and psychosocial harms suffered by patients living with a retained surgical item. Current prevention strategies, including national standards-based professional practices, are not always effective in preventing retained surgical items. An internationally standardised taxonomy and reporting criteria, more consistent reporting, and open access to event and risk data could inform a more accurate global estimate of risk and incidence of this hospital-acquired complication. |
Keywords | Adverse event; Gossypiboma; Retained surgical instrument; Retained surgical item; Retained surgical sponge; Sentinel event; Unintended retained foreign object |
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020 | 489999. Other law and legal studies not elsewhere classified |
420599. Nursing not elsewhere classified | |
Byline Affiliations | School of Nursing and Midwifery |
Queensland University of Technology | |
Griffith University | |
Institution of Origin | University of Southern Queensland |
https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q682w/exploring-risk-antecedents-and-human-costs-of-living-with-a-retained-surgical-item-a-narrative-synthesis-of-australian-case-law-1981-2018
Download files
Published Version
Osborne 2021_exploring-risk--antecedents-and-human-costs-of-living-with-a.pdf | ||
License: CC BY 4.0 | ||
File access level: Anyone |
27
total views24
total downloads0
views this month0
downloads this month
Export as
Related outputs
Effectiveness of interventions to reduce sexually transmitted infections and blood-borne viruses in incarcerated adult populations: a systematic review protocol
Balmer, Amanda, Bromdal, Annette, Mullens, Amy, Kynoch, Kathry and Osborne, Sonya. 2023. "Effectiveness of interventions to reduce sexually transmitted infections and blood-borne viruses in incarcerated adult populations: a systematic review protocol ." JBI Evidence Synthesis. https://doi.org/10.11124/JBIES-22-00444Parents’ knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs regarding influenza vaccination for children under five years of age in Australia: A mixed methods systematic review protocol.
Virta, Eveline, Elliott, Jessica and Osborne, Sonya. 2021. "Parents’ knowledge, attitudes, and beliefs regarding influenza vaccination for children under five years of age in Australia: A mixed methods systematic review protocol."Implementation of the Electronic Medical Record into the Bachelor of Nursing program: A descriptive study
Ng, Linda, Osborne, Sonya and Walker, Jan. 2022. "Implementation of the Electronic Medical Record into the Bachelor of Nursing program: A descriptive study." 44th Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia Annual Conference (HERDSA 2022). Melbourne, Australia 27 - 30 Jun 2022 Australia.Integration of an Academic Electronic Medical Record into the Bachelor of Nursing program: A pilot project
Ng, Linda, Osborne, Sonya and Walker, Jan. 2021. "Integration of an Academic Electronic Medical Record into the Bachelor of Nursing program: A pilot project." Sigma's 32nd International Nursing Research VIRTUAL Congress. Toowoomba, Australia 21 - 23 Jul 2021 Toowoomba, Australia.Introducing a MAP for adherence care in the paediatric cystic fibrosis clinic: a multiple methods implementation study
Richards, Bianca, Osborne, Sonya R. and Simons, Megan. 2022. "Introducing a MAP for adherence care in the paediatric cystic fibrosis clinic: a multiple methods implementation study." BMC Health Services Research. 22 (1), pp. 1-18. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-021-07373-5Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018
Osborne, Sonya, Cockburn, Tina and Davis, Juliet. 2022. "Exploring risk, antecedents and human costs of living with a retained surgical item: A narrative synthesis of Australian case law 1981–2018." Journal of Perioperative Nursing. 35 (2), pp. e-49-e-65. https://doi.org/10.26550/2209-1092.1202Exploration of clinicians’ decision-making regarding transfer of patient care from the emergency department to a medical assessment unit: A qualitative study
Osborne, Sonya R., Cleak, Helen and de Looze, Julian W. M.. 2022. "Exploration of clinicians’ decision-making regarding transfer of patient care from the emergency department to a medical assessment unit: A qualitative study ." PLoS One. 17 (2), pp. 1-23. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0263235Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians
Close, Eliana, Willmott, Lindy, Cockburn, Tina, Young, Simon, Cairns, Will and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Transparent triage policies during the COVID-19 pandemic: a critical part of medico-legal risk management for clinicians." Medical Journal of Australia. 215 (2), pp. 71-74.e1. https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.51079Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?
Close, Eliana, Young, Simon, Cockburn, Tina, Willmott, Lindy and White, Ben P.. 2021. "Legal challenges to ICU triage decisions in the COVID-19 pandemic: How effectively does the law regulate bedside rationing decisions in Australia?" University of New South Wales Law Journal. 44 (1), pp. 9-59. https://doi.org/10.53637/FSJG1698