Developing an appropriate contaminated land regime in China: lessons learned from the US and UK

Authored book


Zhao, Xiaobo. 2013. Developing an appropriate contaminated land regime in China: lessons learned from the US and UK. Springer.
Book Title

Developing an appropriate contaminated land regime in China: lessons learned from the US and UK

Book CategoryAuthored book
ERA Publisher ID3337
Authors
AuthorZhao, Xiaobo
Number of Pages298
Year2013
PublisherSpringer
ISBN9783642316142
9783642316159
Web Address (URL)http://www.springer.com/law/international/book/978-3-642-31614-2
Abstract

Land contamination is regarded as a ‘negative heritage’ of the Industrial Revolution which began in England and subsequently spread to several developed countries in Europe, the United States and some Asian countries during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Large-scale mining and inappropriate disposal of chemicals are considered to be the primary reasons of large-scale land contamination.
Like all industrialized countries, China is experiencing increased land contamination in recent years. Abandoned mining and manufacture sites and obsolete industrial complexes, while also creating new polluting industrial enterprises, are presenting impending environmental threats. More importantly, a number of social and economic problems have developed and must be dealt with, in some cases, as a matter of urgency in China.
In response, contaminated land laws or regulations have been established and have evolved in the US and UK and many other jurisdictions for decades. Regulatory regimes for contaminated land issues are highly systemic and well developed in those countries. Those regimes have substantially influenced the relevant legislation in the context of numerous Asian and European countries. In comparison, legislation as a response to land contamination is a recent thing in China. Regulations and relevant environmental standards for soil protection are under development at both the central and local government levels. However, considering the difficulties facing the lawmakers in developing contaminated land regulatory regimes gaps still broadly exist under China’s current legal system. This book therefore considers what China can learn from the experiences of other jurisdictions, particularly the complex legislation concerning contaminated land in the US and UK. These two countries have developed advanced systems for the control and prevention of contaminated land problems. Consideration of the liability issues, the commercial issues, the relevant science and other areas such as insurance and valuation have, to some extent, also been adopted by numerous countries.
This book aims to examine those issues as they might apply to China based on a comparative study of various mechanisms for the remediation and redevelopment of contaminated lands. The following analysis focuses on three principal areas. First, what is the extent of China’s contaminated land problem? Second, how can we remediate contaminated sites? Finally, how can we redevelop contaminated lands to an acceptable and safe use? Based on this analysis, several recommendations have been provided for consideration and possible areas for future research.
First of all, China should adopt a more flexible contaminated land liability regime, in which the following principles should be considered. Three principles should be considered while developing a liability regime: the polluter pays principle (PPP); the state liability principle and the retroactive liability principle. Second, remediation mechanisms are suggested for the contaminated land regime. A sitespecific based selection process, risk-based land management (RBLM) and the methodology of cost–benefit analysis should be introduced in China as soon as possible. In addition, remediation standards, together with evaluation systems, should also be considered. Third, environmental liability insurance is suggested as an instrument to reinforce environmental liability regimes. Finally, other mechanisms, such as financial incentives, public participation in contaminated land management issues and environmental decision making, contaminated land information management, environmental education and using consultation in contaminated land cases and public interest litigation, are suggested as possible improvements to the existing regime.
This book will be of interest to academics and practitioners in environmental law of China, as well as the US and UK. I believe that those who want to learn more about China's environmental legislation will get reliable information from this book. More importantly, for students who want to trace frontier issues in China's environmental legislation may also benefit from this book, because it demonstrates a whole picture of how the contaminated land law and policy would be made in China.

KeywordsChina comparative law; environmental law; environmental policy; land contamination; risk-based land management
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020480299. Environmental and resources law not elsewhere classified
480302. Comparative law
Public Notes

Files associated with this item cannot be displayed due to copyright restrictions.

Byline AffiliationsShanghai University of Finance and Economics, China
Institution of OriginUniversity of Southern Queensland
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q2w40/developing-an-appropriate-contaminated-land-regime-in-china-lessons-learned-from-the-us-and-uk

  • 1799
    total views
  • 10
    total downloads
  • 1
    views this month
  • 0
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

It’s on like Donkey Kong: How evolving defamation laws put online creators and influencers at risk
Zhao, Bob. 2024. "It’s on like Donkey Kong: How evolving defamation laws put online creators and influencers at risk." UniSQ Newsroom.
Contemporary Australian Tort Law
Kyriakakis, Joanna, Popa, Tina, Rochford, Francine, Szablewska, Natalia, Zhao, Xiaobo, Taliadoros, Jason, O'Donovan, Darren and Bautista, Lowell. 2024. Contemporary Australian Tort Law . Australia . Cambridge University Press.
Foreign Environmental Law
Zhao, Xiaobo, Wang, Binhu, Wu, Chunxiao, Zhang, Yang, Gill, Gitanjali Nain, Pozzo, Barbara, Liu, Mingquan, Han, Chengxun, Li, Xuanyu, Xu, Jianyu, Benassi, Mohammed, Hajba, Mahagoub, Liu, Jing, Liu, Haiou, Wang, Shuyi, Zhang, Xiaohu, Fogelman, Valerie, Qiu, Qiu and Tu, Gang. 2023. Foreign Environmental Law. China. China Social Sciences Press.
Comments on All-China Environment Federation v Scenic Spot Management Council of Wuxi City
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2023. "Comments on All-China Environment Federation v Scenic Spot Management Council of Wuxi City ." Wang, Xi (ed.) Selection of One hundred environmental cases. China. Higher Education Press / Gaodeng Jiaoyu Chubanshe. pp. 419-426
The Standing to Sue of NGOs in Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China: A Doctrinal Analysis of Laws and Cases
Gao, Qi, Ke, Quan and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2023. "The Standing to Sue of NGOs in Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China: A Doctrinal Analysis of Laws and Cases." Wang, Xi, Zhao, Xiaobo and McNamara, Noeleen (ed.) Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China. Switzerland. Springer. pp. 83-110
Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China: An Overview
Zhao, Xiaobo and McNamara, Noeleen. 2023. "Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China: An Overview." Wang, Xi, Zhao, Xiaobo and McNamara, Noeleen (ed.) Environmental Public Interest Litigation in China . Switzerland. Springer. pp. 3-19
Comparative Study of Environmental Public Interest Litigation (EPIL) in Australia and China
Zhao, Bob. 2022. "Comparative Study of Environmental Public Interest Litigation (EPIL) in Australia and China ." Research Showcase with Former High Court Judge Justice Kirby. Ipswich, QniSQ, Australia 01 - 01 Apr 2022 Australia.
Rights-Based Climate Litigation in Australia: New Frontiers
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2022. "Rights-Based Climate Litigation in Australia: New Frontiers." Shanghai Judicial Forum on Frontier Issues 2022 & The Sixth Chongming World-Сlass Ecological Island Judicial Symposium. China 15 - 15 Nov 2022 Australia.
Rights-Based Climate Litigation in Australia: A Critical Review
Zhao, Bob. 2022. "Rights-Based Climate Litigation in Australia: A Critical Review." Environment and Human Rights: Legal Paradigms Symposium. Toowoomba, Australia 18 - 18 Feb 2022 Australia.
Environmental Law in Qld: An Introduction
Zhao, Xiaobo (Bob). 2021. "Environmental Law in Qld: An Introduction ." Comparative Enrivonmental Law Forum at the Shanghai Normal University. Shanghai, China 18 - 18 Oct 2021 Australia.
Contemporary Australian Tort Law
Kyriakakis, Joanna, Popa, Tina, Rochford, Francine, Szablewska, Natalia, Zhao, Xiaobo, Taliadoros, Jason, O'Donovan, Darren and Bautista, Lowell. 2020. Contemporary Australian Tort Law. Cambridge, United Kingdom. Cambridge University Press.
Developing an appropriate contaminated land regime in China: lessons learned from the US and UK
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2019. Developing an appropriate contaminated land regime in China: lessons learned from the US and UK. Berlin, Heidelberg, Germany. Springer.
Contaminated land legislation in China: status quo and challenges
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2011. "Contaminated land legislation in China: status quo and challenges." Journal of Environmental Management and Tourism. 2 (2), pp. 268-275.
Frontier issues of overseas Environmental Law
Qin, Tianbao and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2010. "Frontier issues of overseas Environmental Law." Annual report of overseas humanities and social sciences, 2009. Hubei, China. Wuhan University Press. pp. 430-464
Study on latest developments of Environmental Law in EU and US (2007)
Qin, Tianbao and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2008. "Study on latest developments of Environmental Law in EU and US (2007)." Annual report of overseas humanities and social sciences, 2008. Wuhan University Press. pp. 406-452
Study on latest issues of Environmental Law in Europe and America
Qin, Tianbao and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2007. "Study on latest issues of Environmental Law in Europe and America." Annual report of overseas humanities and social sciences, 2007. Wuhan University Press. pp. 422-482
On the 'Zustandsverantwortlichkeit'under the Federal Soil Protection Act (Bodenschutzgesetz, Bbodschg) of Germany and its referential experience for the contaminated land legislation of China
Zhao, Xiaobo and Qin, Tianbao. 2011. "On the 'Zustandsverantwortlichkeit'under the Federal Soil Protection Act (Bodenschutzgesetz, Bbodschg) of Germany and its referential experience for the contaminated land legislation of China." Johrbuch des Deutsch-Chineseischen Instituts für Rechtswissenschaft der Universitafen Gottingen und Nanjing. 8, pp. 266-274.
Review to typical local contaminated land legislation of Japan
Zhao, Xiaobo and Qin, Tianbao. 2011. "Review to typical local contaminated land legislation of Japan." Journal of Henan Administrative Institute of Politics and Law. 26 (3), pp. 111-115. https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.2095-3275.2011.02.019
Analysis on the exception clauses of CERCLA: with referential experience for China's legislation
Zhao, Xiaobo and Lin, Yougang. 2007. "Analysis on the exception clauses of CERCLA: with referential experience for China's legislation." Humanities & Social Sciences Journal of Hainan University. 25 (4), pp. 393-398.
Soil contamination legislation in Belgium: case study to the Flemish region (English-Chinese translation)
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2008. "Soil contamination legislation in Belgium: case study to the Flemish region (English-Chinese translation)." China Environment and Resource Law Review. 2007, pp. 189-195.
On contaminated land legislation in Japan
Zhao, Xiaobo (Bob). 2018. On contaminated land legislation in Japan . China. Law Press China.
Soil degradation through agriculture in China: its extent, impacts and implications for environmental law reform
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2018. "Soil degradation through agriculture in China: its extent, impacts and implications for environmental law reform." Ginzky, Harald, Dooley, Elizabeth, Heuser, Irene L., Kasimbazi, Emmanuel, Markus, Till and Qin, Tianbao (ed.) International Yearbook of Soil Law and Policy 2017. Cham, Switzerland. Springer. pp. 37-63
Land contamination legislation in China: the emerging challenges
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2017. "Land contamination legislation in China: the emerging challenges." Hideki, Kitagawa (ed.) Environmental policy and governance in China. Japan. Springer. pp. 47-67
Legal regimes of radioactive waste treatment in Japan after Fukushima: an interpretive analysis based on Act on Special Measures Concerning the Handling of Radioactive Pollution’/日本灾后放射性废弃物处置法律制度研究:以《放射性物质污染应对特别措施法》为核心 (in Chinese)
Zhao, Xiaobo(Bob). 2015. "Legal regimes of radioactive waste treatment in Japan after Fukushima: an interpretive analysis based on Act on Special Measures Concerning the Handling of Radioactive Pollution’/日本灾后放射性废弃物处置法律制度研究:以《放射性物质污染应对特别措施法》为核心 (in Chinese)." Journal of Shanghai University of Political Science & Law. 30 (1), pp. 73-82.
The Trans-Pacific Partnership: a quest for a twenty-first century trade agreement (English-Chinese translation)
Zhao, Xiaobo and He, Ling Ling. Lim, C. L., Elms, Deborah K. and Low, Patrick (ed.) 2016. The Trans-Pacific Partnership: a quest for a twenty-first century trade agreement (English-Chinese translation). China. Cambridge University Press.
Adani Mining Pty Ltd v Land Services of Coast and Country Inc & Ors [2015] QLC 48
McNamara, Noeleen and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2016. "Adani Mining Pty Ltd v Land Services of Coast and Country Inc & Ors [2015] QLC 48." Australian Resources and Energy Law Journal. 35 (1), pp. 6-12.
Confidential geodata protection in China: challenges, liability concerns and possible solutions
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2016. "Confidential geodata protection in China: challenges, liability concerns and possible solutions." Frontiers of Law in China. 11 (3), pp. 551-574. https://doi.org/10.3868/s050-005-016-0032-6
Contaminated land law of China: a possible way to achieve food safety?
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2016. "Contaminated land law of China: a possible way to achieve food safety?" Kennedy, Amanda and Liljeblad, Jonathan (ed.) Food systems governance: challenges for justice, equality and human rights. Milton Park, United Kingdom. Routledge. pp. 163-185
Environmental dispute settlement in China
Zhao, Xiaobo and Zhang, Jianwei. 2015. "Environmental dispute settlement in China." Qin, Tianbao (ed.) Research handbook on Chinese environmental law. United Kingdom. Edward Elgar Publishing. pp. 342-367
Environmental liability
Zhao, Xiaobo and Zhang, Jianwei. 2015. "Environmental liability." Qin, Tianbao (ed.) Research handbook on Chinese environmental law. United Kingdom. Edward Elgar Publishing. pp. 320
Developing a national contaminated land liability scheme in China: the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act revisited
Jeffery, Michael I. and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2012. "Developing a national contaminated land liability scheme in China: the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act revisited." Journal of Energy and Natural Resources Law. 30 (4), pp. 423-465. https://doi.org/10.1080/02646811.2012.11435305
Review of regulatory frameworks for contaminated land in China
Zhao, Xiaobo and Zhang, Jianwei. 2013. "Review of regulatory frameworks for contaminated land in China." Frontiers of Law in China. 8 (1), pp. 69-102. https://doi.org/10.3868/s050-002-013-0003-0
Legislation on soil remediation in Belgium (Flemish Region)
Lavrysen, L. and Zhao, Xiaobo. 2007. "Legislation on soil remediation in Belgium (Flemish Region)." Conference in 2007 of China Law Society Association of Environment and Resources Law. Lanzou City, China 12 - 15 Aug 2007 Conference in 2007 of China Law Society Association of Environment and Resources Law.
On Japan's Investigation System for Soil Contamination
Zhao, Xiaobo. 2007. "On Japan's Investigation System for Soil Contamination." Conference in 2007 of China Law Society Association of Environment and Resources Law. Lanzou City, China 12 - 15 Aug 2007 Conference in 2007 of China Law Society Association of Environment and Resources Law.