Who Benefits? World Heritage and Indigenous People
Contribution to Journal
Pocock, Celmara, Lilley, Ian, Pocock, Celmara and Lilley, Ian. 2018. "Who Benefits? World Heritage and Indigenous People." Heritage and Society. 10 (2), pp. 171-190. https://doi.org/10.1080/2159032X.2018.1503836
| ERA Journal ID | 45118 |
|---|---|
| Authors | Pocock, Celmara (Author), Lilley, Ian (Author), Pocock, Celmara and Lilley, Ian |
| Journal Title | Heritage and Society |
| Journal Citation | 10 (2), pp. 171-190 |
| Number of Pages | 19 |
| Year | 2018 |
| Place of Publication | Milton Park, United Kingdom |
| ISSN | 1940-8420 |
| 1940-8439 | |
| 2159-032X | |
| Digital Object Identifier (DOI) | https://doi.org/10.1080/2159032X.2018.1503836 |
| Abstract | This paper provides the context for a continuing research project on the potential benefits of World Heritage Listing for Indigenous people. The benefits of World Heritage listing are regarded as obvious by advocates of the system, but this view is not shared by many Indigenous communities. This paper provides an assessment of the issues that create conflict between the World Heritage system and Indigenous people. A review of academic and policy literature suggests that the World Heritage System is incompatible with many aspects of Indigenous worldviews, and that conflict arises over issues of sovereignty and translation. These deep-seated issues make it impossible for the World Heritage system to stay abreast of Indigenous concerns, and as a consequence World Heritage continues to be a site of protest and contestation for Indigenous people. This discursive essay offers preliminary insights from research currently underway using Australian case studies to explore these issues. |
| Keywords | World Heritage; indigenous; benefits; sovereignty; conflict |
| ANZSRC Field of Research 2020 | 430205. Heritage and cultural conservation |
| Public Notes | Volume date is 2017, but publication date is 2018. Permanent restricted access to Published version, in accordance with the copyright policy of the publisher. |
| Byline Affiliations | School of Arts and Communication |
| University of Queensland | |
| Institution of Origin | University of Southern Queensland |
| Scopus ID | 85051718496 |
| Funder | Australian Research Council |
| Title | Who Benefits? World Heritage and Indigenous People |
| Funding source | Grant ID DP140100360 |
Permalink -
https://research.usq.edu.au/item/q4z46/who-benefits-world-heritage-and-indigenous-people
165
total views12
total downloads0
views this month0
downloads this month
Export as
Related outputs
Visualising heritage landscapes in future: aesthetics, embodiment, and meaning
Pocock, Celmara. 2023. "Visualising heritage landscapes in future: aesthetics, embodiment, and meaning." Brown, Steve and Goetcheus, Cari (ed.) Routledge Handbook of Cultural Landscape Practice. United Kingdom. Routledge. pp. 431-441Custom, conflict and the construction of heritage: European huts on the Tasmanian Central Plateau
Collett, David, Knowles, Joan and Pocock, Celmara. 2023. "Custom, conflict and the construction of heritage: European huts on the Tasmanian Central Plateau." Journal of Community Archaeology and Heritage. 10 (1), pp. 3-23. https://doi.org/10.1080/20518196.2022.2080905World heritage as authentic fake: Paradisic Reef and Wild Tasmania
Pocock, Celmara, Collett, David, Knowles, Joan, Pocock, Celmara, Collett, David and Knowles, Joan. 2022. "World heritage as authentic fake: Paradisic Reef and Wild Tasmania." Landscape Research. 47 (8), pp. 1024-1038. https://doi.org/10.1080/01426397.2022.2115990Great Barrier Reef World Heritage: Nature in danger
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2022. "Great Barrier Reef World Heritage: Nature in danger." Queensland Review. 28 (2), pp. 118-129. https://doi.org/10.1017/qre.2022.8World Heritage and Environment
Pocock, Celmara. World Heritage and Environment. Toowoomba. https://doi.org/10.26192/7x5x-3e98In Community Hands: Memory and the Material Culture Legacy of a Mega Sporting Event: Commemorating the 1982 XII Commonwealth Games in Brisbane
Stell, Marion, Pocock, Celmara, Stell, Marion and Pocock, Celmara. 2019. "In Community Hands: Memory and the Material Culture Legacy of a Mega Sporting Event: Commemorating the 1982 XII Commonwealth Games in Brisbane." INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE HISTORY OF SPORT. 36 (6), pp. 551-569. https://doi.org/10.1080/09523367.2019.1647170Visitor encounters with the Great Barrier Reef: aesthetics, heritage and the senses
Pocock, Celmara. 2020. Visitor encounters with the Great Barrier Reef: aesthetics, heritage and the senses. Milton Park, United kingdom. Routledge.Aboriginal colonial history and the (un)happy object of reconciliation
Palmer, Jane and Pocock, Celmara. 2020. "Aboriginal colonial history and the (un)happy object of reconciliation." Cultural Studies. 34 (1), pp. 49-69. https://doi.org/10.1080/09502386.2019.1602153Better ways of seeing landscapes: The Queensland Historical Atlas
Stell, Marion, Mate, Geraldine, Pocock, Celmara, Stell, Marion, Mate, Geraldine and Pocock, Celmara. 2018. "Better ways of seeing landscapes: The Queensland Historical Atlas." Queensland Review. 25 (2), pp. 267-285. https://doi.org/10.1017/qre.2018.25Contesting the Center
Pocock, Celmara, Jones, Sian, Pocock, Celmara and Jones, Sian. 2018. "Contesting the Center." Heritage and Society. 10 (2), pp. 99-108. https://doi.org/10.1080/2159032X.2018.1457301Raw emotion: The Living Memory module at three sites of practice
Pocock, Celmara, Stell, Marion, Mate, Geraldine, Pocock C., Stell M. and Mate G.. 2018. "Raw emotion: The Living Memory module at three sites of practice." Smith, Laurajane, Wetherell, Margaret and Campbell, Gary (ed.) Emotion, Affective Practices, and the Past in the Present. Abingdon, Oxon and New York. Routledge. pp. 281-303A disconnected journey
Mate, Geraldine, Pocock, Celmara, Mate, Geraldine and Pocock, Celmara. 2018. "A disconnected journey." International Journal of Heritage Studies. 24 (4), pp. 374-389. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2017.1378902Reading indigeneity without race: Color, representation and uncertainty in photographic evidence
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2017. "Reading indigeneity without race: Color, representation and uncertainty in photographic evidence." Hillerdal, Charlotta, Karlström, Anna and Ojala, Carl-Gösta (ed.) Archaeologies of "Us" and "Them": Debating History, Heritage and Indigeneity. Routledge. pp. 140-158Waiting, power and time in ethnographic and community-based research
Palmer, Jane, Pocock, Celmara and Burton, Lorelle. 2018. "Waiting, power and time in ethnographic and community-based research." Qualitative Research. 18 (4), pp. 416-432. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468794117728413Images and other research on the history and heritage of the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. Images and other research on the history and heritage of the Great Barrier Reef. Toowoomba.Nostalgia and belonging: Henry George Lamond writing the Whitsunday Islands
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2015. "Nostalgia and belonging: Henry George Lamond writing the Whitsunday Islands." Queensland Review. 22 (1), pp. 49-61. https://doi.org/10.1017/qre.2015.5Assessing stories before sites: identifying the tangible from the intangible
Pocock, Celmara, Collett, David, Baulch, Linda, Pocock, Celmara, Collett, David and Baulch, Linda. 2015. "Assessing stories before sites: identifying the tangible from the intangible." International Journal of Heritage Studies. 21 (10), pp. 962-982. https://doi.org/10.1080/13527258.2015.1040440Tactile landscape: visitors at the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2010. "Tactile landscape: visitors at the Great Barrier Reef." Sensorial Investigations.You don't know what you don't know: ethics and participant consent issues for eResearch users
Ostini, Jenny, Gacenga, Francis, Pocock, Celmara and Whiteside, Eliza. 2014. "You don't know what you don't know: ethics and participant consent issues for eResearch users." eResearch Australasia 2014 Conference: Towards Unified Global Research. Melbourne, Australia 27 - 31 Oct 2014 Sydney, Australia.Assessment of the indigenous national heritage values for Wurrwurrwuy stone picture site
Collett, David and Pocock, Celmara. 2012. Assessment of the indigenous national heritage values for Wurrwurrwuy stone picture site. Canberra, Australia. Commonwealth Government of Australia.Ask first: a guide to respecting indigenous heritage places and values: issues and gaps analysis
Collett, David and Pocock, Celmara. 2012. Ask first: a guide to respecting indigenous heritage places and values: issues and gaps analysis. Canberra, Australia. Commonwealth Government of Australia.Heritage value of rock art on the Cape York Peninsular: assessment of criterion iii for Cape York World Heritage nomination [Confidential]
Collett, David and Pocock, Celmara. 2012. Heritage value of rock art on the Cape York Peninsular: assessment of criterion iii for Cape York World Heritage nomination [Confidential].Success factors in cultural heritage tourism enterprise management
Carlsen, Jack, Hughes, Michael, Frost, Warwick, Pocock, Celmara and Peel, Vicki. 2008. Success factors in cultural heritage tourism enterprise management. Gold Coast, Australia. Sustainable Tourism CRC.Tourism as theatre: performing and consuming indigeneity in an Australian wildlife sanctuary
Picard, David, Pocock, Celmara, Trigger, David, Picard, David, Pocock, Celmara and Trigger, David. 2014. "Tourism as theatre: performing and consuming indigeneity in an Australian wildlife sanctuary." Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change. 12 (3), pp. 206-223. https://doi.org/10.1080/14766825.2014.933967Aborigines, Islanders and Hula Girls in Great Barrier Reef Tourism
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock, Celmara. 2014. "Aborigines, Islanders and Hula Girls in Great Barrier Reef Tourism." JOURNAL OF PACIFIC HISTORY. 49 (2), pp. 170-192. https://doi.org/10.1080/00223344.2014.897201Reading indigeneity without race: colour, representation and uncertainty in photographic evidence
Pocock, Celmara. 2013. "Reading indigeneity without race: colour, representation and uncertainty in photographic evidence." Hillerdal, Charlotta, Karlstrom, Anna and Ojala, Carl-Gosta (ed.) Archaeologies of 'Us' and 'Them' 2013: Debating the Ethics and Politics of Ethnicity and Indigeneity in Archaeology and Heritage Discourse. Uppsala, Sweden 24 - 26 Oct 2013 Uppsala, Sweden.Imagining paradise, discovering science: tourism and science at the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2013. "Imagining paradise, discovering science: tourism and science at the Great Barrier Reef." Australasian and Pacific Travel in the Middlebrow Imagination 1925-1950: Transported Imagination (2013). Cairns, Australia 28 - 29 Nov 2013Reaching for the reef: exploring place through touch
Pocock, Celmara. 2008. "Reaching for the reef: exploring place through touch." Vanclay, Frank, Higgins, Matthew and Blackshaw, Adam (ed.) Making sense of place: exploring concepts and expressions of place through different senses and lenses. Canberra, Australia. National Museum of Australia Press. pp. 76-85Assessing stories before sites: identifying the tangible from the intangible
Pocock, Celmara, Collett, David and Baulch, Linda. 2013. "Assessing stories before sites: identifying the tangible from the intangible." Lira, Sergio, Amoeda, Rogerio and Pinheeiro, Cristina (ed.) 3rd International Conference on Intangible Heritage 2013: Sharing Cultures. Aveiro, Portugal 24 - 26 Jul 2013 Barcelos, Portugal.Identifying social values in archival sources: change, continuity and invention in tourist experiences of the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2002. "Identifying social values in archival sources: change, continuity and invention in tourist experiences of the Great Barrier Reef." Gomes, F. V., Taveira Pinto, F. and das Neves, L. (ed.) 6th International Symposium: a multi-disciplinary Symposium on Coastal Zone Research, Management and Planning (Littoral 2002): The Changing Coast. Porto, Portugal 22 - 26 Sep 2002 Porto, Portugal.Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, Australia: national parks, changes in perception, and hyper-reality
Pocock, Celmara. 2013. "Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, Australia: national parks, changes in perception, and hyper-reality." Delehanty, Randolph (ed.) Crown jewels: five great national parks around the world and the challenges they face. Washington, DC. United States. American Alliance of Museums Press. pp. 119-135Custom, conflict and the construction of heritage: European huts on the Tasmanian central plateau
Collett, David, Pocock, Celmara and Knowles, Joan. 2012. "Custom, conflict and the construction of heritage: European huts on the Tasmanian central plateau." Australian Anthropological Society Conference (AAS 2012): Culture and Contest in a Material World. Brisbane, Australia 26 - 28 Sep 2012 Canberra, Australia.Real to reel reef: space, place and film at the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2004. "Real to reel reef: space, place and film at the Great Barrier Reef." Ferrero-Regis, Tiziana and Moran, Albert (ed.) Placing the moving image. Brisbane, Australia. Griffith University. pp. 53-68Sensing place, consuming space: Changing visitor experiences of the great barrier reef
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2006. "Sensing place, consuming space: Changing visitor experiences of the great barrier reef." Meethan, Kevin, Anderson, Alison and Miles, Steve (ed.) Tourism, Consumption and Representation: Narratives of Place and Self. Oxfordshire, United Kingdom. CABI. pp. 94-112From segregation to assimilation: a thematic study of policies and practices Australia (1800 to 1970)
Pocock, Celmara. 2008. From segregation to assimilation: a thematic study of policies and practices Australia (1800 to 1970). Brisbane, Australia. Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and the Arts.'Blue lagoons and coconut palms': The creation of a tropical idyll in Australia
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2005. "'Blue lagoons and coconut palms': The creation of a tropical idyll in Australia." Australian Journal of Anthropology. 16 (3), pp. 335-349. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1835-9310.2005.tb00315.xIntroduction: Current directions in Australian anthropologies of the environment
Mulcock, Jane, Pocock, Celmara, Toussaint, Yann, Mulcock J., Pocock C. and Toussaint Y.. 2005. "Introduction: Current directions in Australian anthropologies of the environment." Australian Journal of Anthropology. 16 (3), pp. 281-293. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1835-9310.2005.tb00311.xVisiting the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2010. "Visiting the Great Barrier Reef." Queensland Historical Atlas. Nov 2010, pp. 1-3.A playground for science: Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2010. "A playground for science: Great Barrier Reef." Queensland Historical Atlas. Oct 2010.Survival: how the landscape impacts on people
Pocock, Celmara. 2010. "Survival: how the landscape impacts on people." Queensland Historical Atlas. Dec 2010, pp. 1-5.Distinctiveness: islands
Pocock, Celmara. 2010. "Distinctiveness: islands." Queensland Historical Atlas. Nov 2010, pp. 1-3.Entwined histories: photography and tourism at the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2009. "Entwined histories: photography and tourism at the Great Barrier Reef." Robinson, Mike and Picard, David (ed.) The framed world: tourism, tourists and photography. Farnham, Surrey. United Kingdom. Ashgate Publishing Limited. pp. 185-197Turtle riding on the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock, C. 2006. "Turtle riding on the Great Barrier Reef." SOCIETY & ANIMALS. 14 (2), pp. 129-146. https://doi.org/10.1163/156853006776778789Authenticity in cultural heritage management and tourism
Pocock, Celmara. 2006. "Authenticity in cultural heritage management and tourism." Historic Environment. 19 (2), pp. 3-8.Living memory and the interpretation of heritage: developing a multimedia interactive to record and store personal stories for use in heritage interpretation and research
Pocock, Celmara, Stell, Marion, Frost, Lucy, Crozier, Julia and Ancher, Simon. 2010. Living memory and the interpretation of heritage: developing a multimedia interactive to record and store personal stories for use in heritage interpretation and research. Brisbane, Australia. Sustainable Tourism CRC.Towards a cultural heritage tourism research strategy: developing synergies in Australian research
Pocock, Celmara. 2008. Towards a cultural heritage tourism research strategy: developing synergies in Australian research. Brisbane, Australia. Sustainable Tourism CRC.Tourists riding turtles
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2006. "Tourists riding turtles." Australian Zoologist. 33 (4), pp. 425-435. https://doi.org/10.7882/AZ.2006.015Sense matters: Aesthetic values of the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara and Pocock C.. 2002. "Sense matters: Aesthetic values of the Great Barrier Reef." International Journal of Heritage Studies. 8 (4), pp. 365-381. https://doi.org/10.1080/1352725022000037191What is success in cultural heritage tourism?
Pocock, Celmara. 2012. "What is success in cultural heritage tourism?" Shuter, Claire (ed.) Visitor Research Forum 2012: Interpreting our Heritage and Understanding our Visitors. Brisbane, Australia 18 Jan 2012 Brisbane, Australia.Sense matters: aesthetic values of the Great Barrier Reef
Pocock, Celmara. 2012. "Sense matters: aesthetic values of the Great Barrier Reef." Dudley, Sandra H. (ed.) Museum objects: experiencing the properties of things. London, United Kingdom. Routledge. pp. 241-253This item comprises data from the following sources: Web of Science and Scopus