The role of online discussion forums in supporting learning in higher education

Doctorate other than PhD


McDonald, Jacquelin. 2007. The role of online discussion forums in supporting learning in higher education. Doctorate other than PhD Doctor of Education. University of Southern Queensland.
Title

The role of online discussion forums in supporting learning in higher education

TypeDoctorate other than PhD
Authors
AuthorMcDonald, Jacquelin
SupervisorPostle, Glen
Institution of OriginUniversity of Southern Queensland
Qualification NameDoctor of Education
Number of Pages228
Year2007
Abstract

[Abstract]: This study investigates the contribution of asynchronous, online discussion forums to student learning in an Australian, online postgraduate course. The study of online forums is an emerging field of research and therefore calls for a methodology suited to the context where knowledge and application is still at the exploration stage. Grounded theory – an open, qualitative methodology – was chosen as an appropriate method to explore the nature of the interaction in the online forums.
The grounded theory analysis of the data revealed that participant interaction did generate instructional design knowledge across a range of conceptual levels. The study also showed that interaction was effectively facilitated through the use of asynchronous text-based forums, and that participants used the online interaction to build a learning community and to generate knowledge within the learning community. These findings, although from a small case study, help to justify the widespread use of discussion forums in higher education.
The research findings revealed that participant interaction was a key component that enabled the teachers and learners to build and participate in an online learning community. The subcategories that emerged from participant interaction – teaching role, building a learning community and generating knowledge – were all contributing categories to the core category: interaction as a facilitator of learning. Research revealed that the teacher had an important role in managing and facilitating the interactive online learning environment, through both design and implementation of the course. The teaching role was complex and integral in the building of a learning community and facilitating knowledge generation.
One outcome of particular interest for online researchers is that most of the categories that emerged from the data in this study strongly correlated to the categories in the Interaction Analysis Model (IAM); as well as categories identified by the Canadian Institute of Distance Education Research (CIDER), the research arm of the Centre for Distance Education at Athabasca University. The grounded theory approach in this study generated similar categories to CIDER and IAM, despite the research being conducted without any reference to categories existing in the literature. The correlation between the CIDER, IAM and my categories provides credibility to each set of research outcomes. Also, it can be argued that the correlation between findings of independently conducted research studies means that these categories can be more confidently generalised to other online contexts. While the CIDER categories are now being applied in a number of empirical studies, I suggest that further research in a range of contexts is required to confirm whether these are “the” important variables in online interaction.
The grounded theory approach generated categories unique to this research and provided a framework for the design and implementation of interactive online learning. From these findings, the literature, and personal experience, recommendations are presented in regard to design principles, a design framework, and implementation strategies and tactics. The implications of online learning for institutional policy and practice are outlined, and a reflection on the online teaching role is presented – one that challenges some existing conceptions of a diminished role for online teachers. The debate surrounding the role of teaching in learning-centred pedagogy is an important discussion for higher education.

Keywordsonline learning and teaching; interaction; computer-mediated communication; grounded theory
ANZSRC Field of Research 2020390405. Educational technology and computing
Byline AffiliationsFaculty of Education
Permalink -

https://research.usq.edu.au/item/9y81w/the-role-of-online-discussion-forums-in-supporting-learning-in-higher-education

Download files


Published Version
McDonald_2007_whole.pdf
File access level: Anyone

  • 5955
    total views
  • 2982
    total downloads
  • 12
    views this month
  • 3
    downloads this month

Export as

Related outputs

Learning in the palm of your hand: an exploration of the value of online education-related X/Twitter chats for professional learning
Mercieca, Bernadette Mary, McDonald, Jacquelin and Carpenter, Jeffrey Paul. 2024. "Learning in the palm of your hand: an exploration of the value of online education-related X/Twitter chats for professional learning." Professional Development in Education. https://doi.org/10.1080/19415257.2024.2306995
A Review of the Trends and Challenges in Adopting Natural Language Processing Methods for Education Feedback Analysis
Shaik, Thanveer, Tao, Xiaohui, Li, Yan, Dann, Christopher, McDonald, Jacquie, Redmond, Petrea and Galligan, Linda. 2022. "A Review of the Trends and Challenges in Adopting Natural Language Processing Methods for Education Feedback Analysis." IEEE Access. 10, pp. 56720-56739. https://doi.org/10.1109/ACCESS.2022.3177752
Identifying, building and sustaining leadership capacity for communities of practice in higher education
McDonald, Jacquelin, Star, Cassandra, Burch, Tony, Cox, Milton, Nagy, Judy, Margetts, Fiona and Collins, Emily. 2012. Identifying, building and sustaining leadership capacity for communities of practice in higher education. Sydney. Australian Government Office for Learning and Teaching.
Sustaining the momentum: a cross-institutional community of practice for research supervisors
Cater-Steel, Aileen, McDonald, Jacquie, Albion, Peter and Redmond, Petrea. 2017. "Sustaining the momentum: a cross-institutional community of practice for research supervisors." McDonald, Jacquie and Cater-Steel, Aileen (ed.) Implementing communities of practice in higher education: dreamers and schemers. Singapore. Springer. pp. 3-17
Leading institutional change through learning and teaching communities
Newman, Tara, McDonald, Jacquelin, Partridge, Helen, Jolly, Lesley and Sheppard, Karen. 2015. "Leading institutional change through learning and teaching communities." 12th Annual Conference of the International Society for the Scholarship of Teaching and Learning (ISSOTL2015). Melbourne, Australia 27 - 30 Oct 2015
Leading at the coal-face: the world as experienced by subject coordinators in Australian higher education
Holt, Dale, Cohen, Lynne, Campbell-Evans, Glenda, Chang, Paul, Macdonald, Ian and McDonald, Jacquie. 2013. "Leading at the coal-face: the world as experienced by subject coordinators in Australian higher education." Educational Management Administration and Leadership. 41 (2), pp. 233-249. https://doi.org/10.1177/1741143212468346
Community, domain, practice: facilitator catch cry for revitalising learning and teaching through communities of practice
McDonald, Jacquie. 2012. Community, domain, practice: facilitator catch cry for revitalising learning and teaching through communities of practice. Sydney, Australia. Australian Learning and Teaching Council Limited.
Identifying and building the leadership capacity of community of practice facilitators
McDonald, Jacquelin, Nagy, Judy, Star, Cassandra, Burch, Tony, Cox, Miton D. and Margetts, Fiona. 2012. "Identifying and building the leadership capacity of community of practice facilitators." Learning Communities Journal. 4, pp. 63-84.
Digital communities: context for leading learning into the future?
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquie. 2012. "Digital communities: context for leading learning into the future?" Brown, M., Hartnett, M. and Stewart, T. (ed.) 29th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE 2012). Wellington, New Zealand 25 - 28 Nov 2012 Wellington, New Zealand.
A comparative study of software to aid the development of a conceptual framework for instructional design theory
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2001. "A comparative study of software to aid the development of a conceptual framework for instructional design theory." Kennedy, G., Keppell, Michael, McNaught, C. and Petrovic, T. (ed.) 18th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE 2001). Melbourne, Australia 09 - 12 Dec 2001 Melbourne, Australia.
Charting the role of the online teacher in higher education: winds of change
McDonald, Jacquie and Reushle, Shirley. 2002. "Charting the role of the online teacher in higher education: winds of change." Williamson, Andy, Gunn, Cathy, Young, Alison and Clear, Tony (ed.) 19th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE 2002). Auckland, New Zealand 08 - 11 Dec 2002 Auckland, New Zealand.
Bridging international boundaries: integrating and mentoring teaching roles in an online environment
Reushle, Shirley, McDonald, Jacquelin and Lowe, Wendy. 2003. "Bridging international boundaries: integrating and mentoring teaching roles in an online environment." Crisp, Geoffrey (ed.) 20th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE 2003). Adelaide, Australia 07 - 10 Dec 2003 Wollongong, Australia.
Community learning: member's stories about their academic community of practice
McDonald, Jacquelin, Collins, Pauline, Hingst, Raymond D., Kimmins, Lindy, Lynch, Bernadette and Star, Cassandra. 2008. "Community learning: member's stories about their academic community of practice." 31st Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia Annual Conference (HERDSA 2008). Rotorua, New Zealand 01 - 04 Jul 2008 Sydney, Australia.
The challenges of building an academic community of practice: an Australian case study
McDonald, Jacquelin and Star, Cassandra. 2008. "The challenges of building an academic community of practice: an Australian case study." 31st Higher Education Research and Development Society of Australasia Annual Conference (HERDSA 2008). Rotorua, New Zealand 01 - 04 Jul 2008 Sydney, Australia.
New models for learning flexibility: negotiated choices for both academics and students
Nagy, Judy and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2007. "New models for learning flexibility: negotiated choices for both academics and students." Atkinson, Roger J., McBeath, Clare, Soong, S. K. A. and Cheers, C. (ed.) 24th Annual Conference of the Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE 2007). Singapore 02 - 05 Dec 2007 Singapore. Australasian Society for Computers in Learning in Tertiary Education (ASCILITE).
A conceptual model and evaluation process for educational technology learning resources: a legal case study
McDonald, Jacquie, McPhail, Janelle, Maguire, Michael and Millett, Bruce. 2004. "A conceptual model and evaluation process for educational technology learning resources: a legal case study." Educational Media International. 41 (4), pp. 287-296. https://doi.org/10.1080/09523980410001680914
Designing and implementing online discussion forums: an Australian case study
McDonald, Jacquelin. 2009. "Designing and implementing online discussion forums: an Australian case study." International Journal of Networking and Virtual Organisations. 6 (5), pp. 518-531. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJNVO.2009.027394
Supporting women in engineering, science and technology: the Go West Project
Cater-Steel, Aileen and McDonald, Jacquie. 2010. "Supporting women in engineering, science and technology: the Go West Project." Hudson, Peter, Chandra, Vinesh, King, Donna and Lee, Kar-Tin (ed.) 1st Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics in Education Conference (STEM 2010). Brisbane, Australia 26 - 27 Nov 2010 Brisbane, Australia.
Online teaching and learning in higher education: a case study
Postle, Glen, Sturman, Andrew, Mangubhai, Francis, Cronk, Peter, Carmichael, Ann, McDonald, Jacquie, Reushle, Shirley, Richardson, Lesley and Vickery, Bruce. 2003. Online teaching and learning in higher education: a case study. Canberra, Australia. Commonwealth of Australia.
Engagement in web-based education: designing for models of student learning
McDonald, Jacquelin and Reushle, Shirley. 2000. "Engagement in web-based education: designing for models of student learning." Indian Journal of Open Learning. 9 (3), pp. 287-298.
Online pedagogy as a challenge to the traditional distance education paradigm
McDonald, Jacquelin and Reushle, Shirley. 2001. "Online pedagogy as a challenge to the traditional distance education paradigm." Montgomerie, Craig and Viteli, J. (ed.) World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia and Telecommunications (ED-MEDIA 2001). Tampere, Finland 25 - 30 Jun 2001 Chesapeake, VA. United States.
Responding to the perfect storm: impetus to create an edgeless university?
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2010. "Responding to the perfect storm: impetus to create an edgeless university?" Tait, Alan and Szucs, Andras (ed.) EDEN 2010 Annual Conference: Media Inspirations for Learning: What Makes the Impact?. Valencia, Spain 09 - 12 Jun 2010 Budapest, Hungary.
Go WEST - supporting women in engineering, science and technology: an Australian higher education case study
McDonald, Jacquelin, Loch, Birgit and Cater-Steel, Aileen. 2010. "Go WEST - supporting women in engineering, science and technology: an Australian higher education case study." Cater-Steel, Aileen and Cater, Emily (ed.) Women in engineering, science and technology: education and career challenges. Hershey, PA, United States. IGI Global. pp. 118-132
Determinants of students' acceptance and use of learning resources on CD-ROM
Rose, Janelle and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2005. "Determinants of students' acceptance and use of learning resources on CD-ROM." Shehadie, Elias (ed.) Australasian Business and Behavioural Sciences Association Conference 2005 (ABBSA 2005). Cairns, Australia 05 - 07 Aug 2005 Australia.
What do instructional designers do in higher education? A written symposium
Dempsey, John V., Albion, Peter, Litchfield, Brenda C., Havard, Byron and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2007. "What do instructional designers do in higher education? A written symposium." Reiser, Robert A. and Dempsey, John V. (ed.) Trends and issues in instructional design and technology, 2nd ed.. Upper Saddle River, N.J.. Prentice Hall. pp. 221-233
Evolution and emerging trends of university writing groups
Galligan, Linda, Cretchley, Patricia, George, Lucy, Martin-McDonald, Kris, McDonald, Jacquie and Rankin, Janet. 2003. "Evolution and emerging trends of university writing groups." Queensland Journal of Educational Research. 19 (1), pp. 28-41.
Transformation through technology-enhanced learning in Australian higher education
Reushle, Shirley, McDonald, Jacquie and Postle, Glen. 2009. "Transformation through technology-enhanced learning in Australian higher education." Mayes, Terry, Morrison, Derek, Mellar, Harvey, Bullen, Peter and Oliver, Martin (ed.) Transforming higher education through technology-enhanced learning. Heslington, York. United Kingdom. Higher Education Academy. pp. 58-71
Developing research supervisors: breaking down internal barriers and drawing on resources from the Australasian academic community
Cater-Steel, Aileen and McDonald, Jacquie. 2009. "Developing research supervisors: breaking down internal barriers and drawing on resources from the Australasian academic community." iPED 2009: Researching Beyond Boundaries: Academic Communities Without Borders. Coventry, United Kingdom 14 - 15 Sep 2009 Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
An exploratory qualitative study to determine factors influencing the adoption of mobile learning for tertiary education
Gururajan, Raj, McDonald, Jacquelin, Gururajan, Vijaya and Genrich, Rohan. 2007. "An exploratory qualitative study to determine factors influencing the adoption of mobile learning for tertiary education." International Journal of Technology, Knowledge and Society. 2 (6), pp. 33-40.
Priority areas for research in open and distance education in the 21st century
Taylor, J. C., Postle, G., Reushle, S. and McDonald, J.. 2000. "Priority areas for research in open and distance education in the 21st century." Indian Journal of Open Learning. 9 (1), pp. 99-104.
Online learning: transcending the physical
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2004. "Online learning: transcending the physical." Effective Teaching and Learning Conference (ETL 2004): A Conference for University Teachers. Brisbane, Australia 04 - 05 Nov 2004 Brisbane, Australia.
Moving an Australian dual mode university to the online environment: a case study
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2000. "Moving an Australian dual mode university to the online environment: a case study." Bourdeau, Jacqueline and Heller, Rachelle (ed.) World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia and Telecommunications (ED-MEDIA 2000). Montreal, Canada 26 Jun - 01 Jul 2000 Chesapeake, VA. United States.
Web-based student learning: accommodating cultural diversity
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2000. "Web-based student learning: accommodating cultural diversity." Indian Journal of Open Learning. 9 (3), pp. 351-359.
Attitudes of distance education students towards compulsory virtual teamwork in an undergraduate business course
Birch, Dawn and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2007. "Attitudes of distance education students towards compulsory virtual teamwork in an undergraduate business course." e-Journal of Business Education and Scholarship of Teaching. 1 (1), pp. 14-23.
An exploratory study to determine students' perceptions of the value of interaction in an Australian classroom context and the perceived impact on learning outcomes
McDonald, Jacquelin, Birch, Dawn, Gray, Anthony, Gururajan, Raj, Hingst, Raymond D. and Maguire, Michael. 2005. "An exploratory study to determine students' perceptions of the value of interaction in an Australian classroom context and the perceived impact on learning outcomes." CRLL 2005: What a Difference a Pedagogy Makes: Researching Lifelong Learning and Teaching. Glasgow, Scotland 24 - 26 Jun 2005 London, United Kingdom.
Embedding successful pedagogical practices: assessment strategies for a large, diverse, first year student cohort
Star, Cassandra and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2007. "Embedding successful pedagogical practices: assessment strategies for a large, diverse, first year student cohort." International Journal of Pedagogies and Learning. 3 (2), pp. 18-30.
The changing role of an instructional designer in the implementation of blended learning at an Australian university
McDonald, Jacqueline and Mayes, Terry. 2007. "The changing role of an instructional designer in the implementation of blended learning at an Australian university." Keppell, Michael J. (ed.) Instructional design: case studies in communities of practice. Hershey, PA. United States. IGI Global. pp. 170-192
Making meaning of women's networks: a community of practice framework
McDonald, Jacquelin and Star, Cassandra. 2007. "Making meaning of women's networks: a community of practice framework." Albion, Majella J. and Collins, Pauline (ed.) 2007 International Women's Conference: Education, Employment and Everything... theTriple Layers of a Woman's Life. Toowoomba, Australia 26 - 29 Sep 2007 Toowoomba, Australia.
Designing the future of learning through a community of practice of teachers of first year courses at an Australian university
McDonald, Jacquelin and Star, Cassandra. 2006. "Designing the future of learning through a community of practice of teachers of first year courses at an Australian university." Philip, R., Voerman, A. and Dalziel, J. (ed.) The First International LAMS Conference: Designing the Future of Learning (2006). Sydney, Australia 06 - 08 Dec 2006 Sydney, Australia.
Role of the educator in supporting learning in an online environment: vision for the future
Reushle, Shirley and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2004. "Role of the educator in supporting learning in an online environment: vision for the future." McKay, Elspeth (ed.) International Conference on Computers in Education (ICCE 2004): Acquiring and Constructing Knowledge Through Human-Computer Interaction Creating New Visions for the Future of Learning. Melbourne, Australia 30 Nov - 03 Dec 2004 Melbourne, Australia.
Students' perceptions of a virtual team assessment item (VTAI): An Australian case study
Birch, Dawn and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2005. "Students' perceptions of a virtual team assessment item (VTAI): An Australian case study." 7th ODLAA Conference. Adelaide, Australia 09 - 11 Nov 2005
Engagement by design: marrying pedagogy and technology for better learning conversations via asynchronous electronic discussions
Dorman, Marilyn and McDonald, Jacquelin. 2005. "Engagement by design: marrying pedagogy and technology for better learning conversations via asynchronous electronic discussions." Son, Jeong-Bae and O'Neill, Shirley (ed.) Enhancing learning and teaching: pedagogy, technology and language. Flaxton, Australia. Post Pressed. pp. 101-118
Pedagogically challenged: a framework for the support of course designers in an Australian distance learning university
McDonald, Jacquelin and Mayes, Terry. 2005. "Pedagogically challenged: a framework for the support of course designers in an Australian distance learning university." Caldwell, Joanne, Cleary, Paula, Crossan, Beth, Edwards, Richard, Gallacher, Jim, Gray, Peter, MacFarlane, Karen, McGavock, Karen, Mayes, Nicholas, Miller, Kate, Osborne, Mike, Remedios, Richard, Smith, June and Toman, Nuala (ed.) CRLL 2005: What a Difference a Pedagogy Makes: Researching Lifelong Learning and Teaching. Glasgow, Scotland 24 - 26 Jun 2005 Glasgow, Scotland.